---
title: "Electric Hydronic Heating: Electric Boiler or Heat Pump?"
date: 2026-11-03T11:30:00+11:00
author: Darren Burch
canonical_url: "https://sogeo.com.au/blog/electric-hydronic-heating-electric-boiler-or-heat-pump"
section: Pages
---
![Stiebel Eltron Hydronic Heat Pumps]()

#  Electric Hydronic Heating: Electric Boiler or Heat Pump? 

There are two ways to run hydronic heating on electricity: an electric boiler or a heat pump. Both give the same quiet, radiant warmth. They differ hugely in running cost and in how much power they draw from your switchboard. Here is how to choose.

 

 

 

 

**The short answer.** Electric hydronic heating uses electricity, instead of gas, to heat the water that flows through your radiators or underfloor pipes. An electric boiler turns 1 kWh of electricity into 1 kWh of heat. A heat pump turns the same 1 kWh into roughly 4 to 5 kWh of heat by moving warmth in from the outside air. That makes the heat pump far cheaper to run: about $900 to $1,350 a year for a typical Melbourne home, where an electric boiler delivering the same heat would cost four to five times as much. An electric boiler is cheaper to buy, and it still has a place in small spaces.

## What is electric hydronic heating?

Hydronic heating warms your home with water. A heat source warms the water, a pump circulates it through sealed pipes, and radiators or pipework in the floor release the heat into each room. Electric hydronic heating simply means that heat source runs on electricity rather than gas. Nothing changes in the rooms themselves: you get the same silent, draught-free warmth either way.

Since 1 January 2024, new homes in Victoria that need a planning permit cannot connect to gas, so for many new builds electric is now the only option. If you are new to the system as a whole, start with [what hydronic heating is](https://sogeo.com.au/blog/understanding-exactly-how-hydronic-heating-systems-work-the-basics-for-homeowners). This guide covers the choice that matters most once you go electric.

## Electric boiler vs heat pump at a glance

- **Electric boiler.** Heats water directly with electric elements, like a large kettle. One unit of heat for each unit of electricity. Compact and sits indoors. Cheaper to buy, expensive to run across a whole house, and draws a lot of power at once.
- **Heat pump.** Moves heat from the outside air (or the ground) into the water. Roughly 4 to 5 units of heat for each unit of electricity, and SóGeo installs typically reach a seasonal SCOP of 5 or more. Needs an outdoor unit, costs more to buy, and costs far less to run.

 

 

  01 

 ![Stiebel Eltron Hydronic Heat Pump]() 

 

### How each one makes heat

The two machines can look similar in a plant room, but they work in completely different ways.

**An electric boiler** passes current through heating elements sitting in the water. Every kilowatt hour of electricity becomes one kilowatt hour of heat, and no more. It is simple, silent and reliable, and because it burns nothing it needs no flue. The catch is that it can never be more than 100 percent efficient.

**A heat pump** works like a fridge in reverse. A refrigerant circuit collects low-grade heat from the outside air, raises it to a useful temperature and hands it to the water. The electricity only drives the compressor and fan; most of the heat comes free from outside. That is why a heat pump delivers several units of heat for every unit of electricity, even through a Melbourne winter.

**A ground source (geothermal) heat pump** collects its heat from the ground instead of the air. Because the ground stays at a steady temperature all year, it runs at 5 to 7 units of heat for each unit of electricity, summer and winter.

Both machines connect to the same pipes and the same radiators or floor, so the choice between them changes the running cost and the power draw, not the warmth you feel in the rooms.

 

 

 

## Running costs: why the heat pump wins

For the same amount of heat, an electric boiler uses four to five times the electricity of a heat pump. Using our figures for a typical Melbourne home:

- **Hydronic heat pump:** about $900 to $1,350 a year.
- **Electric boiler, same heat:** roughly $3,600 to $6,750 a year, four to five times the heat pump figure.
- **Gas boiler, for comparison:** about $4,100 a year.

The heat pump figure assumes 20 to 30 kWh of electricity a day over a five-month winter at $0.30 per kWh. So an electric boiler can cost as much as gas to run, or more. Switching from gas to an electric boiler swaps one big heating bill for another. Switching to a heat pump brings it down to roughly a quarter to a third of the gas figure.

## Will your power supply cope?

This is the part most guides skip. An electric boiler draws its full heat output from your switchboard, so a 12 kW boiler pulls 12 kW of electricity whenever it runs flat out. On a single-phase supply that is about 52 amps for the heating alone, before the oven, the hot water or an electric car charger.

A heat pump delivering the same 12 kW of heat draws only a fraction of that, because most of the heat comes from outside. That smaller draw is often the difference between using the supply you already have and paying for a switchboard or three-phase upgrade.

Before any electric heating goes in, it is worth checking your home’s maximum demand. Our free [maximum demand calculator](https://sogeo.com.au/tools/maximum-demand-calculator) shows how heating and hot water choices change it.

## Converting gas hydronic heating to electric

If you already have gas hydronic heating, going electric is usually a swap of the heat source, not a new system. In most homes the radiators and pipework stay, the gas boiler comes out and a heat pump goes in. A SóGeo boiler-to-heat-pump swap that keeps your radiators starts at $15,000. See [replacing a gas boiler with a hydronic heat pump](https://sogeo.com.au/replace-gas-boiler-hydronic-heat-pump).

Two things decide how well it works:

- **Size it to the house, not the old boiler.** Gas boilers were often far bigger than the home needed. A heat pump is sized from a room-by-room heat-loss calculation, which usually lands well below the old boiler rating.
- **Check the radiators.** A heat pump runs cooler water than an old gas boiler. Most radiators cope; where a room falls short, a larger panel lets the whole system run cooler and cheaper.

If your boiler has failed and you are weighing your options, our guide on whether to [repair, replace or switch your boiler](https://sogeo.com.au/blog/hydronic-heating-boilers-repair-replace-or-switch) walks through the decision.

## Electric floor heating vs hydronic underfloor heating

Electric floor heating, usually thin mats or cables under tiles, is a different product from hydronic underfloor heating, even though both warm the floor.

- **Electric mats and cables:** cheap to install and thin enough to fit under new tiles. Like an electric boiler, they turn one unit of electricity into one unit of heat, so they suit a bathroom or a small area rather than a whole house.
- **Hydronic underfloor heating:** pipes in the slab or screed carry warm water from a heat pump, so every unit of electricity delivers roughly 4 to 5 units of heat. It costs more to install and far less to run across a whole home. More on [hydronic underfloor heating](https://sogeo.com.au/hydronic-heating-cooling/hydronic-underfloor-heating-comfort-efficiency).

## When an electric boiler does make sense

- **No room for an outdoor unit.** Some apartments and townhouses simply have nowhere to put a heat pump.
- **A small heating load.** A small, well-insulated space, where the running cost difference stays modest.
- **Occasional use.** A space heated now and then, where the lower purchase price matters more than efficiency.

For a typical Melbourne family home heated through winter, a heat pump almost always wins over the life of the system.

## Electric hydronic heating and solar

Running on electricity means your heating can use your own solar power. Warming the house, or the water in the system, during the day lets the slab or the stored water carry that heat into the evening. Because a heat pump turns each solar kilowatt hour into four to five of heat, it gets far more out of your panels than an electric boiler can.

## Are there rebates for electric hydronic heating?

Not for the space-heating system itself. There is currently no Victorian rebate for hydronic heating, whether it runs on a heat pump or an electric boiler. The rebates you may have read about apply to hot water heat pumps, which are a separate measure. If your project includes an eligible hot water upgrade, those programs can apply to that part of the work.

## Which one should you choose?

For most Melbourne homes, a heat pump. It costs more on day one, far less every winter after that, and it is much kinder to your switchboard. An electric boiler is the specialist choice for small or hard-to-place systems.

To go deeper, see the [heat pump hydronic heating](https://sogeo.com.au/air-source-heat-pumps) systems we install, read our [Melbourne homeowner’s guide](https://sogeo.com.au/blog/heat-pump-hydronic-heating-melbourne-guide), or check current prices in our [hydronic heating cost guide](https://sogeo.com.au/blog/how-much-does-it-cost-to-switch-from-gas-to-hydronic-heat-pumps).

 

 

  

## Electric hydronic heating questions

  

### Does electric hydronic heating use a lot of electricity?

 ➕ 

With a heat pump, a typical home uses about 20 to 30 kWh a day in the colder months. An electric boiler delivering the same heat would use four to five times that.

   

### Can I convert my gas hydronic heating to electric?

 ➕ 

Yes. In most homes the gas boiler is replaced with a heat pump and the existing radiators and pipework stay. The swap starts at $15,000.

   

### Do I need three-phase power for electric hydronic heating?

 ➕ 

Not always. A heat pump sized to your home’s heat loss draws far less than an electric boiler, so many homes run one on their existing supply. A whole-house electric boiler is much more likely to need a supply upgrade. We check your switchboard and maximum demand before quoting.

   

### Can an electric hydronic system heat my hot water too?

 ➕ 

Yes. A hydronic heat pump can also heat a hot water tank. Adding a stainless-steel tank adds approximately $4,000 to $5,000, and the heat pump can heat the tank within about an hour.

   

### Is an electric boiler cheaper to install than a heat pump?

 ➕ 

Usually, yes. It is smaller, sits indoors and needs no outdoor unit. The day-one saving is soon used up by running costs four to five times higher.

   

### Can I keep my existing radiators?

 ➕ 

In most homes, yes. We check each room against the heat-loss calculation, and where a radiator falls short at heat pump water temperatures, a larger panel fixes it.

   

### Is there a rebate for electric hydronic heating in Victoria?

 ➕ 

Not for the space-heating system itself. Victorian rebates apply to hot water heat pumps, which are a separate measure.

  

 

  

  01 

 ![SoGeo Team At Work]() 

 

Thinking about hydronic heating for your home? Here is how we get from the first conversation to a fixed price.

Every install starts the same way. We come to the property, measure heat loss room by room, walk through your goals for the system, and write a fixed quote against the design. No estimates, no surprises, no pressure.

For a deeper read on what’s involved before quoting day, visit our pillar page on [hydronic heating Melbourne](https://sogeo.com.au/hydronic-heating-cooling). For installation pricing detail, see our [cost guide](https://sogeo.com.au/blog/how-much-does-it-cost-to-switch-from-gas-to-hydronic-heat-pumps). For boiler replacements and retrofits specifically, our [boiler to hydronic heat pump replacement page](https://sogeo.com.au/replace-gas-boiler-hydronic-heat-pump) covers the most common scenario we see in Melbourne homes.

 [SóGeo designs and installs hydronic heating systems across Melbourne. If you'd like a fixed quote for your home, the next step is a site visit and a heat loss calculation.](https://sogeo.com.au/contact-us) 

 

## Our Partners

   [ ![Reece](https://sogeo.com.au/uploads/suppliers/_AUTOx96_crop_center-center_none_ns/Reece.png) ](https://www.reece.com.au/)   [ ![Stiebel Eltron](https://sogeo.com.au/uploads/suppliers/_AUTOx96_crop_center-center_none_ns/Stiebel-Eltron.png) ](https://www.stiebel-eltron.com.au/)   [ ![Mitsubishi](https://sogeo.com.au/uploads/suppliers/_AUTOx96_crop_center-center_none_ns/Mitsubishi.png) ](https://www.mitsubishielectric.com.au/)   [ ![Purmo](https://sogeo.com.au/uploads/suppliers/_AUTOx96_crop_center-center_none_ns/Purmo.png) ](https://www.purmo.com/au)   [ ![Viessmann](https://sogeo.com.au/uploads/suppliers/_AUTOx96_crop_center-center_none_ns/viessmann_wordmark_rgb_1_vitorange.png) ](https://www.viessmann.com.au/)
